Judith Lynn Petty | Waverly, WV

View full case details

3 Likes

So to me it’s way too much of a coincidence that her body happened to be in an area at the family farm that just happened to “burn” down. Whatever could have been discovered by finding her body intact had been burned away. Someone familiar with the farms cellar etc would be a person of interest. Who is the person claiming she went to return movies? Who found the body?

1 Like

User107 below is the timeline.
Saturday, February 09, 2008 12:00pm

Judy’s remains discovered ( her remains were discovered by her father, he must of been digging for something) ?? Weird

Thursday, February 07, 2008 09:00am

Fire discovered at family farm (fire discovered by her father which drove here for some reason and pulls up to house in flames and then reports it, supposedly the driveway was muddy and fire trucks couldn’t make it up them easily is why the house burnt down completely).


Thursday, February 07, 2008 12:30am

Judy reportedly picked up by Chris ( have not found evidence of who this is or its true)


Wednesday, February 06, 2008 10:00pm

Judy reported missing


Wednesday, February 06, 2008 02:30pm

Judy left residence on foot. (Witnesses that knew her said its not a normal thing for her to be walking through town, she was a type 1 diabetic and plus she was her mothers caretaker).

Well, first things first. The movies being returned is a great place to start. Not only because they may have been returned by someone else, but also because it was stated that “No video had showed her returning them”. This indicates the possibility that this may have been someone she knows, is familiar with but most importantly, may have worked at that library and had access to the video equipment that showed her returning the movies. Those DVR systems they use are pretty easy to manipulate if you understand how they work.

I too find it a bit strange the father just seemed to know where to go right off the bat. So my next question would be, is there any reason to suspect that he would have been harboring any ill intent toward her? Were they in a disagreement or argument of some kind? Etc. Obviously the body can’t tell us much as it’s pretty clear this individual went through a lot to cover their tracks in this case. This was obviously someone who was familiar with her family’s property which also could possibly point to her knowing the individual she may have been with. Interesting case but more details are definitely a need here.